The beloved character of Anne Shirley, known for her vibrant imagination and passionate spirit, faces pivotal moments across various adaptations of Lucy Maud Montgomery’s classic novels. Episode 16 often marks significant transitions and challenges for Anne, whether it’s the notorious “raspberry cordial” incident or her courageous step into higher education.
The Infamous Raspberry Cordial Incident (1979 Animated Series & Book Adaptation)
In the 1979 animated series Anne of Green Gables and closely following the original novel, Episode 16, titled “Diana is Invited to Tea with Tragic Results,” depicts a humorous yet devastating misunderstanding. Anne, left in charge while Marilla is away, invites her bosom friend Diana Barry over for tea. Intending to serve a delightful raspberry cordial, Anne accidentally gives Diana red currant wine, mistaking it for the non-alcoholic drink.
Diana, unaccustomed to alcohol, becomes quite intoxicated, much to Anne’s innocent confusion. When Mrs. Barry discovers her daughter’s state, she is furious, believing Anne intentionally got Diana drunk. Despite Marilla’s attempts to explain it was an innocent mistake, Mrs. Barry is unyielding and forbids Diana from ever playing with Anne again, plunging Anne into profound despair at the thought of losing her only friend. This episode highlights Anne’s endearing naiveté and the dramatic consequences of her well-intentioned blunders.
Embracing Change and New Horizons (Anne with an E – Season 2, Episode 6)
In the Netflix and CBC series Anne with an E, the sixth episode of Season 2, “I Protest Against Any Absolute Conclusion,” also serves as a significant juncture for Anne, albeit with a different set of challenges and character developments.
This episode sees Anne adjusting to a shocking new look after attempting to dye her hair raven black and ruining it, forcing her to sport a very short haircut. While she grapples with her appearance, the town of Avonlea prepares for its annual Christmas pantomime.
A major plot point is the return of Gilbert Blythe to Avonlea, accompanied by Sebastian “Bash” Lacroix, whom he met on his travels. Bash’s arrival introduces new dynamics to the community, as he is from a different background and initially finds Avonlea’s winter climate and unfamiliar customs challenging. The episode also delves into the Christmas play, where Cole Mackenzie, Anne’s friend, breaks his wrist due to an incident involving Billy Andrews, showcasing themes of jealousy and unintended harm. Matthew Cuthbert also takes a more prominent role in the play, a rare public appearance for the usually reserved character. This episode emphasizes themes of friendship, self-acceptance, and the broadening of horizons for several characters, including Anne, Gilbert, and Bash.
Stepping into Womanhood and College Life (2025 Anne Shirley Anime Series)
For the recently released 2025 Anne Shirley anime series, Episode 16, titled “It’s Nicer Not To Know,” marks a momentous transition for Anne. Having made the crucial decision to attend Redmond College, this episode showcases her initial days at the institution alongside Gilbert and Priscilla Grant.
The move to Kingsbury and Redmond College signifies Anne’s first major step into womanhood and away from the familiar comfort of Avonlea. The episode explores the initial struggles new students face in settling into higher education, but also highlights Anne’s inherent charm and character, which help her navigate these new challenges. Elements of the changing times are subtle, such as the appearance of electric streetlights and steam-powered ships, juxtaposed with Anne’s contemplation of history in an old cemetery. The introduction of characters like Philippa Gordon, representing the “New Woman” ideal of first-wave feminism, further underscores Anne’s journey of self-discovery and independence. While focused on her academic pursuits, the episode also subtly touches upon the burgeoning romantic tension with Gilbert Blythe, which Anne deliberately tries to ignore.
Across these various adaptations, Episode 16 consistently serves as a critical juncture for Anne Shirley, reflecting her enduring spirit as she faces challenges, navigates relationships, and embraces the journey of growth and self-discovery.
