“Black Butler: Emerald Witch Arc” continues to weave its captivating spell, and Episode 4, titled “His Butler, Serving,” is a testament to the series’ ability to blend dark mystery with moments of unexpected levity. This episode advances the overarching plot while offering intriguing glimpses into character dynamics and backstories.
A Butler’s Promise: Sebastian’s New Role
The episode primarily focuses on Sebastian fulfilling his promise to Sieglinde Sullivan, the Emerald Witch, by serving as her butler until he can find a way to cure Ciel of his amnesia. This situation presents a fascinating shift in dynamics. Sebastian, usually the unflappable and impeccably mannered demon butler, finds himself navigating the eccentric world of Wolfsschlucht and the peculiar habits of its young leader.
- Etiquette Lessons: One of the highlights of the episode is Sebastian’s attempts to teach Sieglinde proper table manners. These scenes are both humorous and insightful, highlighting Sieglinde’s isolated upbringing and Sebastian’s adaptability. He patiently guides her through the intricacies of silverware usage and dining etiquette, a stark contrast to her previous “savage” eating habits.
- Village Mistrust: Sebastian’s presence doesn’t sit well with everyone. The village women, led by Hilde, express their mistrust of outsiders and blame Wolfram for allowing Ciel and his household to stay. They warn Wolfram of the trouble this situation will bring, adding to the tension and sense of unease surrounding Wolfsschlucht.
- Hidden Motives: While Sebastian is unquestionably serving Ciel by ingratiating himself with Sieglinde, it is clear that he is also trying to get closer to the truth Ciel has been tasked with finding. That truth may very well lurk in the secret cellar he’s found.
Ciel’s Fragile State: Finny’s Crucial Role
Nearly half the episode is dedicated to Ciel, who remains bedridden and traumatized by his encounter in the forest. He’s gripped by amnesia and terror, making it impossible for most people to approach him.
- Finny’s Compassion: Finnian emerges as a key figure in Ciel’s recovery. As the youngest member of the Phantomhive household, he is the only one Ciel trusts enough to be around without succumbing to panic. Finny’s gentle and caring nature allows him to coax Ciel into eating something, even if it’s just milk with honey.
- Shared Trauma: Finny’s ability to connect with Ciel stems from his own traumatic past as a human experiment. Sebastian even mentions to Sieglinde that Ciel was intended to be a human sacrifice in a devil-worshipping ritual.
- The Heroic Ideal: Ciel naming Finny was inspired by Finn MacCool, giving the previously unnamed boy an ambition. Saving Ciel is saving Finny’s world, after all.
Unveiling the Past: Hints of Dark Experiments
Episode 4 provides subtle hints about the sinister experiments conducted on children, including Finny, adding another layer of darkness to the narrative.
- Distrust of Adults: The disturbing experiments explain why Ciel isn’t to be trusted around adults.
- Hidden Symbolism: Sullivan caught a glimpse of the symbol on Sebastian’s hand, so there’s a strong chance she has ulterior motives of her own for accepting him as her butler until his master is healed.
Dub Considerations
The “Emerald Witch Arc” introduces German characters, adding another layer to the voice acting. While Sarah Wiedenheft does a good job voicing Sieglinde, her accent can be a bit too strong for easy comprehension.
Foreshadowing and Mysteries
- Sebastian’s Discovery: The episode concludes with Sebastian discovering a secret cellar, hinting at the dark secrets hidden within Wolfsschlucht. This discovery promises to propel the investigation forward and uncover the truth behind the curse.
- The Werewolf’s Curse: Sebastian explains that those who are exposed to the werewolf’s curse become distorted and beastlike, and the only cure is the Emerald Witch’s magic.
Themes and Analysis
- Isolation and Trauma: Both Ciel and Sieglinde are portrayed as isolated figures burdened by their past traumas. Ciel’s amnesia and fear, coupled with Sieglinde’s confinement to Wolfsschlucht, highlight the devastating effects of isolation and the struggle to overcome past experiences.
- The Cost of Responsibility: Both Ciel and Sieglinde, despite their young age, carry immense responsibilities. Ciel is the Queen’s Watchdog, tasked with solving complex and dangerous cases, while Sieglinde is the Emerald Witch, responsible for protecting her village. The episode explores the burden these responsibilities place on them and the sacrifices they must make.
- Appearance vs. Reality: The episode challenges the perception of witches and curses, prompting viewers to question what is real and what is merely superstition. Ciel’s initial skepticism contrasts with the increasingly apparent supernatural elements, blurring the line between reality and folklore.
Final Thoughts
“Black Butler: Emerald Witch Arc” Episode 4 strikes a delicate balance between advancing the central mystery and exploring the emotional depths of its characters. The episode leaves viewers with a sense of unease and anticipation, eager to uncover the secrets hidden within Wolfsschlucht and witness Ciel’s journey toward recovery. With its compelling characters, dark themes, and intriguing plot twists, the “Emerald Witch Arc” continues to be a captivating addition to the “Black Butler” series.
