“Black Butler: Emerald Witch Arc” Episode 10, titled “His Butler, Mopping Up,” delivers a mix of action, intrigue, and the introduction of new players in the supernatural world. While some found the episode shorter than desired due to a lengthy recap, it sets the stage for the remaining episodes of the arc. Here’s a detailed breakdown of the episode:
Recap and Initial Impressions
Several reviews mention a significant portion of the episode dedicated to recapping previous events. While recaps can be helpful, some viewers felt it detracted from the episode’s overall content and made it feel shorter. Despite this, the episode is generally considered enjoyable, with praise for its action sequences and the introduction of new characters.
Plot Summary
The episode continues Ciel and Sebastian’s investigation into the mysterious deaths and the curse surrounding the Werewolf Forest in Germany.
- The Tank’s Introduction and Destruction: A significant event is the appearance of an armored mobile tank, which attacks Ciel (disguised as Sieglinde). Sebastian swiftly destroys the tank, showcasing his demonic power and protecting Ciel. The destruction of the tank results in the deaths of Anna, Hilde, and others inside.
- Wolfram’s Revelation: Wolfram realizes that the German army, and possibly Sieglinde’s mother, never intended for Sieglinde to live. This revelation shocks him, as his purpose has always been to protect and care for her.
- The Sulin Gas: Diedrich, Baldroy, and Snake continue their mission, carrying the briefcase containing the “sulin gas” to meet up with Finny’s group.
- Introduction of Sascha and Ludger: The episode concludes with the introduction of two Grim Reapers, Sascha and Ludger, who arrive to collect the souls of those who died in the tank explosion.
Key Events and Analysis
Sebastian’s Devilish Best
Sebastian’s actions in this episode highlight his dual nature. He is fiercely protective of Ciel, ensuring his safety at all costs, while also displaying a gleeful ruthlessness in dispatching threats. His destruction of the tank is a prime example, showcasing his power and efficiency.
Wolfram’s Loyalty and Conflict
Wolfram’s character is further developed as his dedication to Sieglinde is tested. His realization about the army’s intentions creates a conflict within him, as he grapples with the betrayal and the need to protect Sieglinde from those who seek to exploit her. Some reviews express hope that Wolfram survives the arc, highlighting his role as a loyal protector.
Historical Inaccuracy
Some viewers noted the historical inaccuracy of a mobile tank appearing in the 1890s, as tanks were not invented until World War I. However, it’s also acknowledged that “Black Butler” exists in an alternate history where supernatural elements are real, allowing for some deviation from historical accuracy.
Symbolism
The tank is referred to as an “oven” by Sebastian, drawing a parallel to the fairy tale of “Hansel and Gretel,” where Gretel pushes the witch into her own oven. This symbolizes Sebastian’s role in carrying out a narrative directive where “witches burn,” as Anne and the others are presented as witches to the outside world.
The Grim Reapers
The introduction of Sascha and Ludger adds another layer to the supernatural aspect of the series. Their presence signifies the consequences of the events unfolding and hints at a larger world beyond Ciel and Sebastian’s immediate concerns.
Themes and Interpretations
Loyalty and Betrayal
The episode explores the themes of loyalty and betrayal through Wolfram’s character arc. His unwavering loyalty to Sieglinde is contrasted with the betrayal by the German army, forcing him to question his beliefs and motivations.
Protection and Manipulation
Sieglinde’s situation highlights the theme of protection versus manipulation. While Wolfram seeks to protect her, others attempt to manipulate her for their own purposes, using her intelligence and abilities for military gain.
Good vs. Evil
The episode touches on the idea of devils and demons being better than witches, subverting traditional fairy tale tropes. Sebastian’s actions, while ruthless, are ultimately in service of protecting Ciel, blurring the lines between good and evil.
Unanswered Questions and Future Implications
Sascha and Ludger’s Role
The exact role of Sascha and Ludger in the larger story remains unclear. Their appearance suggests that the Grim Reapers may have a more significant part to play in the events to come.
Wolfram’s Fate
Wolfram’s future is uncertain as he grapples with the revelation about the army’s intentions. Whether he will continue to protect Sieglinde or take a different course of action is yet to be seen.
The Sulin Gas
The purpose and potential impact of the “sulin gas” remain a mystery. Its significance will likely be revealed in future episodes.
Reception
- Pacing: Some reviews mention that the episode felt rushed.
- Recap: The recap was longer than some viewers would have liked.
- Animation: The animation quality was praised.
- Enjoyment: Despite its flaws, the episode was still considered enjoyable.
Overall
“Black Butler: Emerald Witch Arc” Episode 10 is a transitional episode that sets the stage for the arc’s climax. While some aspects, such as the lengthy recap, were criticized, the episode’s action, character development, and introduction of new elements contribute to the overall narrative. The episode leaves viewers with several unanswered questions and anticipation for the remaining episodes.
