Episode 5 of Black Butler: Emerald Witch Arc continues the investigation into the mysterious deaths and supernatural occurrences in the isolated German village of Wolfsschlucht. Ciel Phantomhive, still reeling from the werewolf attack, grapples with vulnerability, while Sebastian delves deeper into the secrets surrounding the Emerald Witch and the werewolves.
The Lingering Effects of the Miasma
The episode opens with Ciel displaying uncharacteristic vulnerability, muttering about not being worth protecting. This behavior stems from the werewolf miasma he was exposed to, which seems to be having a profound psychological effect. He is trapped in a dreamlike state, struggling with trauma and responsibility.
Sebastian’s Investigation
While Ciel recovers, Sebastian continues his investigation, focusing on the underground chamber beneath the Emerald Witch’s castle. He seeks to uncover the truth behind the Emerald Witch’s connection to the werewolves and the rituals performed in the village. Snake assists Sebastian in his investigation.
Unveiling the Secrets of Wolfsschlucht
The episode reveals more about the peculiar social structure of Wolfsschlucht. The women of the village express their disapproval of outsiders, hinting at a deeper secret. Oscar’s revelations about Anne’s scent suggest a connection between the women and the werewolves, leading to two possible theories: either the women are werewolves themselves, or they have a close cohabitation with the werewolves.
Theories About the Werewolves
- The women are the werewolves: This theory suggests the women possess magical abilities or use herbs and costumes to appear as werewolves, maintaining their secluded lifestyle. Alternatively, they could be actual werewolves capable of transforming into women.
- Cohabitation: This theory suggests the werewolves live alongside the women, explaining the continued presence of women in the village. However, it raises questions about the lack of men and Wolfram’s role, unless men are removed from the village at birth or raised elsewhere.
Queen Victoria’s Involvement
Queen Victoria remains a key player in the overarching plot. A plant analysis report, sent by Ciel before the werewolf attack, reaches the Queen. Her interaction with a doll resembling her deceased husband reveals her unstable mental state and her determination to eliminate the “scary wolves” in Wolfsschlucht. John Brown, the Queen’s messenger, arrives with a letter, indicating the Crown’s direct involvement and a potential acceleration of events.
Sieglinde’s Balancing Act
Sieglinde appears to be caught between her duties as the Emerald Witch and her yearning for the outside world. She understands her responsibilities but is also curious about the world beyond the forest, which is why she allows Ciel and his entourage to stay. However, the villagers make it clear that she is risking something by allowing them to remain.
Episode Highlights
- Ciel’s vulnerability: The episode showcases a rare glimpse into Ciel’s emotional struggles, highlighting the psychological impact of the werewolf miasma.
- Sebastian’s unwavering dedication: Despite Ciel’s condition, Sebastian remains focused on his duty, delving deeper into the mysteries of Wolfsschlucht.
- The intricate social dynamics of Wolfsschlucht: The episode raises questions about the roles of the women and the werewolves, hinting at a complex and potentially sinister relationship.
- Queen Victoria’s agenda: The Queen’s actions and interactions suggest a hidden agenda and a willingness to use violent means to achieve her goals.
Questions Raised
Episode 5 leaves viewers with several unanswered questions:
- What is the true nature of the werewolves and their connection to the women of Wolfsschlucht?
- What secrets lie hidden beneath the Emerald Witch’s castle?
- What does Queen Victoria’s letter contain, and how will it impact Ciel’s investigation?
- Will Ciel recover from the effects of the werewolf miasma?
- What is Wolfram’s true allegiance, and is Sieglinde aware of everything that is happening in her village?
Overall Impression
Episode 5 of Black Butler: Emerald Witch Arc is a compelling installment that balances character development with plot progression. It raises intriguing questions about the mysteries of Wolfsschlucht and sets the stage for shocking revelations. The episode’s blend of supernatural elements, psychological depth, and political intrigue continues to make the Emerald Witch Arc a captivating addition to the Black Butler series. The animation effectively enhances the storytelling, particularly in the ritual sequences and Ciel’s dreamlike state.
