Episode 5 of “Anne with an E,” titled “Tightly Knotted to a Similar String,” is a pivotal episode in the series, marking significant moments of growth, challenges, and heartwarming connections for Anne Shirley and those around her. This episode intricately weaves together themes of burgeoning womanhood, the complexities of friendship, glimpses into hidden family dynamics, and the ever-present yearning for acceptance and belonging.
Spelling Bees and Womanly Woes
The episode begins with a spirited spelling bee where Anne and Gilbert Blythe find themselves as the last two standing. Their academic rivalry is palpable, highlighting their sharp intellects and competitive spirits. Anne emerges victorious, but soon after, she experiences a significant and bewildering event – her first period.
Confused and frightened by the unexpected blood, Anne believes she is dying. Marilla steps in to explain that Anne is entering womanhood. Anne’s initial reaction is one of distress; she declares she’s not ready to be a woman. This scene poignantly captures the anxieties and uncertainties associated with the onset of puberty, a topic that was considered quite taboo during the time period in which the show is set.
The Raspberry Cordial Debacle and a Friendship in Crisis
Eager to impress Diana, Anne prepares a tea party. Marilla allows her to serve raspberry cordial. Unbeknownst to Anne, the bottle she selects isn’t the harmless cordial but red currant wine. As the girls enjoy their tea, they become increasingly giddy and intoxicated, toasting to womanhood and sharing secrets.
Mrs. Barry arrives to find Diana in a state of intoxication. She is appalled and immediately blames Anne for corrupting her daughter. Despite Marilla’s attempts to explain the misunderstanding, Mrs. Barry forbids Diana from seeing Anne again.
The separation is devastating for both girls. Anne and Diana tearfully pledge eternal love and friendship, exchanging locks of hair as a token of their bond. The school day becomes unbearable as Mr. Phillips rearranges the seating, separating Anne and Diana. This separation highlights the rigid social expectations and the devastating consequences of perceived scandal in the close-knit community of Avonlea.
Glimpses into Gilbert’s World
Episode 5 offers a glimpse into Gilbert’s home life, revealing a layer of complexity to his character. Gilbert is shown caring for his ailing father, who is bedridden and possibly uses a wheelchair. He also handles household finances, demonstrating a level of responsibility beyond his years.
When Gilbert is forced to miss school to care for his father, Mr. Phillips asks Anne to deliver Gilbert’s schoolwork. Anne reluctantly agrees. During the visit, Gilbert’s father compliments Anne’s red hair and speaks kindly of her. Seeing Gilbert’s home life softens Anne’s opinion of him. This scene hints at a deeper understanding and perhaps the beginning of a shift in Anne’s perception of Gilbert.
Matthew’s Quiet Affection and a Gift of Puff Sleeves
Matthew’s gentle and observant nature shines through in this episode. He notices Anne’s longing for a dress with puff sleeves, a fashionable detail that would help her feel more accepted by her peers. Overcome with shyness, Matthew initially flees the dress shop. He later returns and enlists the help of Jeanie, an old acquaintance, to have a dress made for Anne.
Matthew asks Jerry to pick up the finished dress and deliver a button from his best suit to Jeanie. When Anne receives the dress, she is overcome with emotion. The puff sleeves represent more than just a fashion statement; they symbolize Matthew’s love and acceptance, and his desire for Anne to feel beautiful and valued.
Themes and Significance
- Coming of Age: The episode explores the physical and emotional challenges of adolescence. Anne’s first period and the girls’ experimentation with alcohol represent steps toward womanhood, albeit with some missteps along the way.
- Friendship: The bond between Anne and Diana is tested by societal pressures and parental disapproval. Their forced separation highlights the importance of loyalty and the pain of lost connection.
- Family: The episode delves into the complexities of family, both chosen and biological. Matthew’s efforts to provide for Anne, Gilbert’s devotion to his father, and the glimpses into Marilla’s past reveal the diverse ways in which families support and shape individuals.
- Social Class and Expectations: The strict social expectations of Avonlea are evident in Mrs. Barry’s reaction to Diana’s intoxication and the pressure Anne feels to conform to the prevailing standards of beauty. The desire for puff sleeves symbolizes Anne’s yearning for acceptance and belonging within her community.
“Tightly Knotted to a Similar String” is a significant episode in “Anne with an E”. It showcases Anne’s resilience in the face of adversity, the deepening connections between characters, and the exploration of universal themes that resonate with audiences of all ages.
